Thursday, 26 September 2019

Some aspects of printing practice

The second number of Bembridge School Newspaper, published in the Spring 1920, records that the printers’ first work that term had been ‘to distribute the type of last term’s magazine’. One hopes they took care. ‘Dissing’ was always a chore, for the printing enthusiasts as much as for everyone else. It was often dirty work, as the type may not have been particularly well cleaned and might even be still wet with paraffin. In this condition a full stick of type for dissing was grim to contemplate. But the work had to be done accurately. Even then, confidence in dissing letters and punctuation well might not extend to spacing material. Thick spaces were easy enough but I can remember as a boy the effort of will, sometimes, required to distinguish thin and middle: I think the space boxes were often the first part of a type-case to get into disarray. But when one considers how perhaps fifty individual third and fourth formers, variously motivated (to say the least), were at different times using the same half dozen or so type-cases, the scope for muddle starts to become apparent. I can remember wandering with a last-minute job from frame to frame trying to find the least ‘foul’ case. (In an emergency, one might be given access to the office and the Printer’s private case and experience there the extraordinary luxury of finding that every sort one picked up was the right one.)



Extreme responses to the frustration and boredom of dissing included on one occasion, I recall, a boy simply picking up handfuls of type from his stick and sprinkling them like broadcast seed over the type-case. Another witness remembers seeing a boy quietly pocketing handfuls of type from his stick and at the end of the session walking over the football field and hurling them in disgust over the cliff. The type-cases used the most often – 12pt Caslon  – were commonly in a more or less foul state. For the conscientious compositor, this meant slow work, as every second or third sort had to be replaced in the right compartment before another attempt was made to secure the right one. But where the boy compositor had been (perhaps) happily chatting to his neighbour as he worked (the motto ‘A still tongue makes a full stick’ adorned the printing room wall before the war) the extent of his mistakes might only become apparent when his work was proofed.

‘The setting-up is exceedingly well done though the sorting still needs greater accuracy,’ remarks the school newspaper in the Spring 1923. But then in the Summer 1924: ‘This term has been chiefly notable for the much greater skill in distribution’. How long did it last? It would be quite wrong to assume that the fact that the matter is not mentioned again in the school newspaper for another three decades means that it did not continue to be an issue; more likely, it was so well established a problem as to be no longer worthy of comment. The Christmas 1960 number reports that the lower forms of the senior school had then been reorganised, allowing ‘more periods of printing [in] much smaller groups’ and there had been in consequence a notable improvement in workmanship, except distribution: ‘Here much more care must be taken, for bad distribution means a great deal of correction in the galley if the compositor does not take great care with his work’.

In 1959, while visiting Oxford as part of the arrangements for the publication of Ruskin’s Diaries, edited by Joan Evans, Jim Dearden became acquainted with the antiques dealer and private press bibliographer William Ridler and for a dozen years or so from the mid-1960s sent him for his collection an annual packet of Yellowsands proofs, trials and dummies, etc. These are now in the John Johnson Collection. They contain some spectacular examples of careless schoolboy setting. (The sheer number of mistakes often reminds one of the specimens of corrected setting which usually accompany the table of proof correctors’ marks in printers’ manuals or authors’ guides to printing - to which a note is sometimes added reminding the reader that this is of course not the frequency of error which will ever be found in practice.)

Occasionally, the compounding of error with misplaced skill achieves a kind of sublimity. In one proof, the text of a hymn, the first lines have been methodically indented, at first glance to accommodate a drop initial letter to be inserted later – except that, carefully centred in the space created there is a small figure in parenthesis: it’s the number of the piece of copy being set. The parentheses are as close as the compositor has been able to get to the circle in the manuscript indicating that the matter within it is not to be set.

Five years in to his long tenure as Printer Dearden compiled some Notes & Rules for Compositors at the Yellowsands Press (1964) which appears to be the only surviving such reference work produced by the Press. It’s a sixteen-page style guide cum printers’ glossary cum index of common errors, and provides an interesting (and not wholly predictable) reflection of some of the problems and potential mishaps of composing room practice.

Accented letters: When setting accented letters, it must be remembered that the accent is reversed on the type.

Confused letters: The following pairs of letters are frequently confused, especially in distributing: b d, p q. The letter on the actual piece of type is reversed, so that when the type is examined, the nick being downwards, the ‘b’ looks like a ‘d’, ‘p’ like ‘q’, and vice versa.
The letters ‘u’ and ‘n’ are frequently inverted and used in place of each other. This, too, should be avoided…

Care should be taken to differentiate between o (oh) and 0 (nought). Study the examples to see the different shapes…

Leads & reglets: Care should be taken to use leads and reglets that are the same length as the line of type.

Spacing: To justify a line of type the spaces must be changed working outwards from the centre using (when spacing up) combinations of spaces in the correct sequence as shown in the table of comparative spaces. It is not permissible to put in an extra space to fill up a line.
Spaces may be put at the end of a line only if it is the last line of a paragraph or a line of verse. In these cases the largest space used should be put at the end of the line.
There is no space between a word and the punctuation following it.

Titles: must be set in the type specified on the manuscript.

Correcting poorly spaced setting could be particularly demanding, lacking the reward of the immediate clarification of language. One vice was the impatient forcing-in of spacing material. In the worst cases, the compositor might actually contrive to gradually increase the line length to which his composing stick had been adjusted. Sometimes it was quicker just to start again.

It’s remarkable, looking through Bembridge School Newspaper over the seven decades of its existence, how few typos there are – and how few indications, in the notes on the activities of the printing room, of the extraordinary feat of proof-reading and correction that lay behind the exclusion of error. But the consequence of this was that the common, amateur printer’s bias in favour of accuracy in composition, over careful presswork, was entrenched.

Doubtless there were boys – there must have been many of them over the years - who interested themselves in the arts of making ready and achieving a consistent quality of impression on the Albion, but such was the vigour of the publishing imperative at Bembridge, conditions in the printing room were frequently against them. As one observer has noted, working the hand press was often treated as a kind of sport, ceasing, at times, to be a printing exercise at all. In the fifty-four years of printing before the Newspaper was finally put on machine*, phases of sustained improvement in presswork tend to coincide with either the arrival of a new Printer, obviously intent on making his mark, or (an even rarer event) the purchase of new type. Certainly, in the 1960s - perhaps the high point of printing at Bembridge School - such tasks as the preparation of the tympan or the adjustment of the platen, were largely the province of the Printer. There being no general investment in them on the part of the boys, standards of presswork might easily slip. Nevertheless, term after term, the Newspaper was got out. Though it was still then the custom for masters to address even the most junior boys in the senior school as young adults, somehow expecting them thereby to behave as such, we were most of us still children, and we were having fun.

*Spring number, 1973. It was a change Dearden always regretted, but as he explained, it had became necessary because in the busy final weeks of term the availability of a team of four printers, as and when each forme was ready, could no longer be relied upon. The printing of the Newspaper was transferred to a Furnival vertical platen acquired from Lightbown’s, of Ryde, a few years before.



















Thursday, 19 September 2019

List of sources


Collections and archives


Bembridge Heritage Centre, Bembridge. Two files of material relating to Bembridge School assembled by local historian John Woodward.

Bodleian Library, Oxford. John Johnson Collection. 99/00-37 Yellowsands Press. Packets of proofs, trial pages, dummies, etc., mainly relating to the Nine Lessons & Carols service books of the 1960s and 70s. Originally collected by the private press bibliographer William Ridler.

Isle of Wight County Records Office, Newport. Whitehouse Archive. AC96/52. An index compiled by Jim Dearden covers about one third of the archive.

Oxford University Press archives. Correspondence of John Johnson.

Ruskin Library, University of Lancaster. Yellowsands Press collection, including a complete set of Bembridge School Newspaper. Not catalogued but a checklist is appended to this article.

Ryde School, Bembridge Boarding House. Bembridge School archives stored mainly in the common room, formerly the Lower Gallery, New House. Material formerly in the attic was transferred to Ryde, 2018-19.

Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, Toronto. Yellowsands Press collection. 35 boxes, including a complete set of Bembridge School Newspaper, otherwise material mainly from c.1960 on. A box list is available from the library.



Books and articles


Bembridge School Newspaper 1:1 – 74:220, 1919-92.

DAY (Robin) Grand inquisitor: memoirs. London: Weidenfeld, 1989.

Dearden (J.S.) ‘John Howard Whitehouse, 1973-1955’, article, first published in 2004, in the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography.

______ Notes & rules for compositors at the Yellowsands Press. Bembridge: Yellowsands Press, Summer 1964.

______ Printing at Bembridge School. Totland Bay: M.J. Conder, January 1965.

______ Printing at Coniston. Bembridge: Yellowsands Press, June 1958.

______ Rambling reminiscences. A Ruskinian’s recollections. London: Pallas Athene, 2014.

______ Ruskin, Bembridge and Brantwood: the growth of the Whitehouse Collection. Keele: Ryburn Publishing, 1994.

[Dearden (J.S.)] A Yellowsands bibliography, 1919-1969. Bembridge: Yellowsands Press, 1969.

EAGLES (Stuart) ‘Ruskin’s ‘true disciple’?: John Howard Whitehouse (1873-1955) and Ruskin’s legacy’, pp. 232-61, in After Ruskin. The social and political legacies of a Victorian prophet, 1870-1920. Oxford: OUP, 2011.

HEATH-STUBBS (John) Hindsights. London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1993.

MORGAN (M.C.) Bryanston 1928-1978. Blandford, 1978.

RIDLER (William) British modern press books. A descriptive checklist of unrecorded items. New ed. 1975.

STEDMAN (T.M.) Bembridge School. The first forty years. Bembridge: Yellowsands Press, June 1959.

STEWART (W.A.C.) The educational innovators. Volume II: progressive schools 1881-1967. London: Macmillan, 1968.

WAKEFORD (Brian) Today well lived. The Bembridge School story, 1919-1994. Bembridge, [1994].

WHITEHOUSE (J. Howard) An account of the Yellowsands Press. Edited by James S. Dearden. Bembridge: Yellowsands Press, 1961.

______ Ed. Bembridge. An historical and general survey by members of Bembridge School. Oxford: Printed at the UP, 1923.

______ Creative education at an English school. Cambridge: Printed at the UP, 1928.

______ The craftsmanship of books. London: Allen & Unwin, 1929.

______ Education. London: Rich & Cowan, 1935. A volume in the ‘In my time’ series. Others included Marriage by Marie Stopes, Music by Hubert J. Foss, Literature by Compton Mackenzie and Art by Frank Rutter.

______  Ed. The English public school. A symposium. 1919.

______ Thy youth and cause. Cambridge: Printed at the UP for the Yellowsands Press, 1934.

WILDMAN (Stephen) [Compiler] Keeper of the flame. John Howard Whitehouse 1873-1955. [Catalogue of an exhibition at the] Ruskin Library, Lancaster University, 30 April – 2 October 2005. Includes essays by J.S. Dearden and Stuart Eagles.